Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms? Jeff Zeitlin (30 May 2019 23:00 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Cian Witherspoon
(30 May 2019 23:26 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Cian Witherspoon
(30 May 2019 23:28 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Vareck Bostrom
(31 May 2019 00:41 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Cian Witherspoon
(31 May 2019 01:25 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Ashley Greenall
(31 May 2019 11:55 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Evyn MacDude
(02 Jun 2019 03:49 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Kurt Feltenberger
(31 May 2019 00:13 UTC)
|
Re: [TML] Has Marc Miller Opened a Can of Worms?
Richard Aiken
(02 Jun 2019 05:50 UTC)
|
With the publication of his /Traveller/ novel, /Agent of the Imperium/, Mr Miller shows that the Imperium has a higher TL in the mental sciences - or that certain technologies relating thereto are actually possible at lower tech levels - than we perhaps thought. We now have clear textev for saying that in the early centuries of the Imperium, the technology existed to record [human] minds (albeit destructively) and to write such a recorded mind onto any [human] brain, at least temporarily. More, we can say that this is "generally" known, as anyone who has ever knowingly dealt with an Agent of the Imperium can readily reach that conclusion. Given that the general tech level of the Imperium has increased in the not-quite-a-millennium since the earliest scenes of the novel, a number of similar technologies become plausibly available: Consider James White's /Sector General/ series of stories, in which the doctors at Sector Twelve Multispecies General Hospital can all "carry" similar mind recordings of doctors of other species. The principal difference between the /Sector General/ (SG, henceforth) version of the technology and the /Agent of the Imperium/ (AotI, henceforth) version is that the SG version does not overwrite/blot out, even temporarily, the "host's" own knowledge and personality. Thus, we can plausibly create a planetary version of Sector General on any polyspecific world. Or, consider H. Beam Piper's /Paratime/ series, of which the best-known story is probably /Lord Kalvan of Otherwhen/. When working "out-time", paratimers acquire the knowledge needed to function within an out-time society (such as language and cultural /mores/, and some skills) through 'hypno-mech'. With proper 'hypno-mech', and possibly some stealthy observation, a paratimer can 'pass' well enough to fool an out-timer into thinking that the paratimer was what Orson Scott Card called "Utlänning", in the Hierarchy of Foreignness from the "Enderverse". Piper's Hypno-mech model is far more impersonal than the SG or AotI models - but does that make it any less plausible? Piper never provides any details about his 'hypno-mech', so one could plausibly guess that it is in part similar to ... ... "Training", from Crawford Kilian's /Chronoplane Wars/ series. Training (always written with an initial capital, even midsentence) allows the Trainable person to acquire and process information at extremely high speeds (equivalent of thousands of WPM), with near-eidetic retention. If you allow Training in your /Traveller/ universe, you can use it as a basis for having a Mnemonic Service (see Isaac Asimov's novella "Sucker Bait"); the brief portrayals of the capabilities of Trainables in the Chronoplane Wars strongly suggest the ability to gather and correlate information to at least the same extent that Asimov used Asperger's-Syndrome-like tendencies to explain Mark Annuncio's abilities that made him so valuable to a Service whose job was to find those obscure correlations that actually _meant_ something, and report them. And Kilian's Trainables don't need keepers like Dr Sheffield. Taking another tack, we can recall Jack Chalker's /Four Lords of the Diamond/ tetralogy, specifically #2, /Cerberus: A Wolf in the Fold/. In this story, it was possible for people to swap minds between bodies, and there was a subtext that the most favored would, when they got old, get new young bodies. We also saw that minds could be swapped into android bodies, effectively giving the favored mind immortality. While this was done with an artificial organism in /Cerberus/, the technology from /Agent/, or future developments of it, would seem to allow the same thing. Is this a Dark Secret of the Imperium? The other side of the technology raises some questions, as well: In /Agent/, the host's memories and personality were suppressed for the duration of the Agent's presence. If this is a separable aspect of the technology, and you also have Training (which is stated that could Train ethics and loyalty, though Kilian's government made such illegal) and/or hypno-mech, you have the possibility of turning colonization missions into straitjacketed societies like that of Safehold in the eponymous series by David Weber. One could quite possibly give oneself nightmares about what the Solomani Party could do with it... Comments/Discussion? ®Traveller is a registered trademark of Far Future Enterprises, 1977-2018. Use of the trademark in this notice and in the referenced materials is not intended to infringe or devalue the trademark. -- Jeff Zeitlin, Editor Freelance Traveller The Electronic Fan-Supported Traveller® Resource xxxxxx@freelancetraveller.com http://www.freelancetraveller.com Freelance Traveller extends its thanks to the following enterprises for hosting services: onCloud/CyberWeb Enterprises (http://www.oncloud.io) The Traveller Downport (http://www.downport.com)