I don't really know myself what causes ice ages (another research topic!) but I suspect from an astronomical point of view that if aphelion occurs at the same time as the winter solstice in the hemisphere with the lesser amount of water that would do it. As the aphelion will precess over time in a perturbing system that would cause periodic ice ages. I get about a 108,000 year precession for Earth perihelion, mostly caused by the presence of Jupiter, but I don't really know if that's caused by long term instability of my numeric system or if it's an accurate-ish representation. It does get pretty close to the reality of 110k years, but that could be a false friend. 

As Home's single gas giant is in a much more distant orbit, I'm not sure if the effect would be as pronounced, something to investigate. 

The word "Tropic" implies a latitude +/- axial tilt from the equator (bounded by the northern and southernmost locations that the sun can appear directly overhead) so sticking to that word, Home is indeed more "tropical" than Earth in there is a wider band within the tropics. 

If you take "tropical" to mean "warm and humid with mild/warm temperatures year round" that could be brought about (I would think) in a planet with a dense atmosphere and a lot of water, giving for high heat capacitance and very effective heat transport around the planet. As mentioned in the seasons article on Wikipedia, the planet Venus does not effectively have any seasons, thanks to the mass of its atmosphere. Before I'd want to suggest that sort of planetary environment for Traveller players I'd like to at least build up a model that represented that sort of climate behavior. 

The solstice does move around, but never very much, and to an extent the definition of the seasons is arbitrary anyway, so why not arbitrarily align it with some astronomical phenomenon? 

In terms of Traveller and this world (Home) it's an interesting thought exercise as to how those definitions would develop, and as Home has no moon there isn't a time period similar to a "month" to align things against, which might serve to make the behavior of the sun in the sky even more significant for calendar definition. 





-------- Original Message --------
On February 19, 2018 1:48 PM, Phil Pugliese (via tml list) <xxxxxx@simplelists.com> wrote:


A local weather lady has stated more than once that DEC1 is just a matter of convenience since the solstice moves around & never happens at the beginning of the month.
I do remember once there was an email from a viewer that asked, "Why not JAN1?". She said that it was probably cuz' DEC seems more 'wintery' than MAR & who would want Xmas to fall in the autumn? She also said that all the weather orgs use DEC1.

p.s. as far as the TU goes, what about worlds w/ climes corresponding to a terran ice-age? Or tropical from pole-to-pole? Looking at our planet as an example either could occur in the same orbit.


From: Caleuche <xxxxxx@sudnadja.com>
To: "xxxxxx@simplelists.com" <xxxxxx@simplelists.com>
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2018 1:56 PM
Subject: [TML] Seasons, Seasonal Lag, sun position and calendars

One incidental item I needed to prepare for play on a planet's surface was determination of the seasons. On the face of it, that's pretty easy: 


I compute the angle between the (normalized) direction vector to the sun and the direction vector of the axis of planet rotation and compute the angle between them (arccos( dot(sunvec, axisvec) ). The year on this planet [Home] happens to be 405.346 days long, the sidereal rotation period is exactly 24 hours, and as mentioned a few times already the tilt of the rotation axis relative to the ecliptic plane is 31 degrees. Astronomical seasons quite obviously fall out of it: if the angle between the rotation axis and direction to the sun is less than 90 degrees and the sign of the first derivative is negative, it's spring. If the angle is less than 90 degrees and the sign is positive, it's summer, > 90 degrees and sign positive it's fall, and > 90 and sign negative it's winter. So in the above plot, the first 101 days are spring, the next are summer, and so on. 

That works for earth in astronomical seasons as well and many people will say, for example, that (northern hemisphere) winter starts on the winter solstice, usually around December 21 or so. However, you'll run into to people that say that winter starts on December 1st, spring starts on March 1st and so on. 

Looking through wikipedia as to why this would be I came across seasonal lag, noting that due to the large amount of water on earth, that mass of water acting as something like a thermal capacitor. In Traveller world generation needs, this means the higher the hydrographics of the world, the longer the delay will be between the astronomical seasons and the thermometric seasons. Adding to the difficulty in generating a simple model to represent this, the lag isn't symmetric for summer and winter. A single location can have a short wintertime lag and a long summertime lag. As far as I can tell, this isn't mentioned or represented in traveller rules and I imagine is generally left to referee whim, or not dealt with at all. 

Home has a different orbit situation than Earth. Aphelion occurs 5 days after the fall equinox, rather than mid summer. If, like earth, the continents are arranged in such a way that more of the land mass is in the northern hemisphere that will probably amplify the effect of northern hemisphere winter in addition to the greater axial tilt and further distance from the system star (which is the same luminosity as the sun), but that's not modeled at all yet. 

This still leaves the question as to why December 1 marks the start of winter for many people. Thermometric seasonal lag works the other direction, if anything, January 1 should mark the start of winter rather than December. It seems like this definition came about arbitrarily in 1780, and I suspect that part of the reasons that December got counted as winter is that there was generally snow on the ground by december 1 in northern europe back then. 

On a world like Home, it's quite likely that snow would appear on the ground far earlier than the equivalent of December 1 on europe-equivalent latitudes, at a guess. I also suspect that the population would have to cluster much more around the equator, due to the more intense winter and (possibly?) truncated growing season thanks to the slightly increased orbital distance. 

This all is certainly overkill in a gaming environment in which even a UWP is considered too much information, but it's fun. 




-----
The Traveller Mailing List
Archives at http://archives.simplelists.com/tml
Report problems to xxxxxx@simplelists.com
To unsubscribe from this list please go to 
http://archives.simplelists.com

-----
The Traveller Mailing List
Archives at http://archives.simplelists.com/tml
Report problems to xxxxxx@simplelists.com
To unsubscribe from this list please go to 
http://www.simplelists.com/confirm.php?u=0og3DHdoRHgL9lI7peOXYWnk6UF4c1zE