To look at the same thing in a different way:

It's fun to experience some of the texture of a particular period of time and the values therein and the ways that period differs from our own time and values.

On the other hand, the standards of the 18th century would NOT fly, even in the countries where it originated, in the world of today. And similarly, I would expect that with the progress of tech levels from perhaps 4 or 5 to 9, that this would be a general reality. The odds of people putting up with some of those standards of treatment of beings still persisting at higher tech levels and after thousands of years is ... remote... in my view.

Royalty now, even only 200-350 years from the inspiration of Traveller, feels precarious and I could see many Royals fading to much smaller roles and expenses. And that is because once ideas our out there that these sorts of autocrats are not required, then there will be movements to remove them and grant more rights to the average citizen.

Now, it may be tolerated to some extent as a useful structure to manage the overall structure of interstellar trade and defence in a snail-mail message delivery empire. But even then, likely only insofar as the individual citizens on their planets are largely left to make choices (some may choose to live in a dictatorship.... people have strange notions).

To me, this suggests the Imperial government as a trade and overall defence overlay, with some additional agencies and programs that have an Imperial component but also integrate or liaise with local agencies and programs of similar natures (in which case the Imperial layer is simply a way to pull together disparate agencies or programs attempting similar tasks on different planets so as to leverage shared knowledge and best practices).

The idiosyncrasies and 'prerogatives' of the nobles would be tolerated to extents and would mostly be in Courts or official events, otherwise the average citizens would hear little about things beyond their own world (or a few worlds in any direction). Much of the shenanigans of empire would occur in the lands of the ultra rich and not seen by most.

The times that the Imperium could be seen and much protest created would be when the Imperium asserts its power and tromps on local rights or where it makes decisions driven by egos or self-interest from the ruling class rather than good public policy. In those cases, the Imperium may face complaints, criticisms, and pressure from planets and NGOs and it may choose then to moderate whatever policy or strategy was setting the public aflame.

Tom B

On Wed, Jun 3, 2020 at 9:31 PM Kelly St. Clair <xxxxxx@efn.org> wrote:
Fair warning, I've not read the original novel(s) that low berths were
apparently stolen, er, taken from wholesale; but from what others have
posted, it sounds like it was presented there as (somehow
simultaneously) both an "ad hoc" repurposing of something meant for
transporting livestock AND as something in common enough use, presumably
by the truly desperate, that the custom of betting on how many live
bodies you got out the other end was well-established.

Again, I suppose that fits with the Age of Sail "coffin ships" mindset,
but I surmise that the gradual shift or evolution over successor
rulesets is due to an (IMO reasonable) assumption that few people living
in, or with access to, a society capable of interstellar travel are
going to put up with a method with a failure rate equivalent to the
ship's steward/purser meeting you at the gangplank with a loaded pistol
and requiring you to put it to your temple and pull the trigger before
boarding.

--
---------------
Kelly St. Clair
xxxxxx@efn.org

-----
The Traveller Mailing List
Archives at http://archives.simplelists.com/tml
Report problems to xxxxxx@simplelists.com
To unsubscribe from this list please go to
http://www.simplelists.com/confirm.php?u=RDHE7iRpfwqlHvVvWBIhpJZsbTiD5NnL