The near-C rock discussion is almost easier to swallow: a technology appeared on the scene that changes the rules of the universe. There's a different problem with planetary systems that have been supposedly around for at least hundreds of millions of years that would destabilize almost immediately and that is regrettably built into the system generation rules. To an extent Traveller brought this on itself, in Book 6 it lists equations that can be derived from Newtonian gravitation thus implies that the universe operates by those rules and invites players to exercise those rules but collapses when some of the examples are tested at more than a surface level. Like a sore tooth that you can't help but push at, it's kind of hard to leave it alone. In part because it feels like it could be fixed. 

That's a diversion from the point of stellar scale engineering structures being cool and fun, but I think I had it in my mind probably from 8th grade to when I had a class that touched on perturbation analysis that Klemperer Rosettes were stable because I presumed Niven inserted them into the Ringworld universe for that reason. Cool as Niven and Traveller are, make sure you don't base any part of your perception of reality on them. 


On Fri, May 1, 2020 at 6:29 PM Jonathan Clark <xxxxxx@att.net> wrote:
Vareck Bostrom wrote:

>     FWIW, once one of the members of a Klemperer Rosette loses its perfect
>     geometric position with respect to the others the "flying off in all
>     directions" happens very quickly and it's only a few orbital periods
>     before it is clearly destabilized.

I'm happy to believe that you are correct. I no longer possess the math
skills to work this out :-) At any rate, this reduces to a discussion
about the potential reaction time of a technological system that is well
beyond our current conception.

>     So the existence of planetary drives might
>     actually be in heavy use throughout the Imperium.

Of course, this impinges on the whole near-C rock discussion which has
wracked this list from time to time. I prefer to 'kick the ball down the
road' and push the whole problem out into the not-easily-imagined
post-Traveller Universe. YMMV.

Jonathan
-----
The Traveller Mailing List
Archives at http://archives.simplelists.com/tml
Report problems to xxxxxx@simplelists.com
To unsubscribe from this list please go to
http://www.simplelists.com/confirm.php?u=wkJZDVdDoS21PvuTrsXSMsmho7pwDsoN